4 Things To Consider When Your Campaign Isn’t Converting

By July 14, 2016Affiliate Marketing

We’ve all been there…

We’ll run a metric-ton of clicks to an offer and conversions just aren’t there.  But why?

This is the type of thing that keeps me up at night, because I just have to know.

Performance Marketing can be a beast of its own some days, and at times, one cannot explain why an offer works so well one day and absolutely tanks the next.

Yesterday, I had lunch with one of my industry buddies, and we agreed that we would just take the good days with the bad days, and in the end, most everything always works out.

However, this doesn’t mean you shouldn’t investigate what exactly is going on…

Especially with mobile traffic, there is likely a reason why things aren’t working.

Direct Link or Pre Lander

The first question I typically will ask a media buyer or affiliate – are you direct linking or running a pre-lander?

With high-volume mobile media buys, sometimes you can get away with direct linking an offer.  But for this to really workout it has to have an aggressive conversion flow (such as one-click or two-click billing).  This is when the user hits the landing page and can confirm or deny the subscription.

Even with this aggressive conversion model, most of the time the traffic has to be absolutely laser targeted.  Most of this time means a certain OS such as Android with a specific mobile carrier.  At most traffic sources, this greatly increases your cost per click, so you want to have a nice budget.

But if you’re direct linking, and it’s not working, wouldn’t it make sense to whip up a couple of quick landing pages to see if you could help the conversion rate?  This is the first step I take as typically I can think up a way to help people convert better.

Also read: When To Use A Pre-Lander vs. Direct Link?

When Are You Testing The Offer?

Especially with mobile traffic, day of the week and/or time of day makes a big difference in conversion rate.

If you’re just turning on traffic for a quick 30 minute test, you could be setting yourself up for immediate failure.

I suggest that you let a campaign run at least a full 24 hours before making any critical decisions.  Most adservers allow you to spread out your budget and even set a frequency cap, so you can do this.  I always recommend a 2×24 (show no more than 2 times per unique visitor in 24 hours) and letting my spend spread across the initial 24 hour period.

If there is no way your budget allows for this, then at least test from 5:00 p.m. – 10:00 p.m. (with mobile offers).

Historically, the best days for mobile conversions are Thursday – Sunday.  Sometimes I won’t even set media buys live until Wednesday evening, but if you’re limited on budget, you want to try to plan your initial testing around these days.

Sometimes a traffic source will penalize you for pausing, so you may want to speak with their trafficking team before you launch and outline these specifics.  Another option is to lower your CPC bid during the “off peak” hours or days.

Where Is The Traffic Coming From?

Another big variable is where is the traffic coming from?  Specifically, what are the end-users doing when they come across your ad (surfing, searching, watching, etc.)?

In most cases, display banner traffic is going to be the best quality because the user has already been pre-qualified because your banners grabbed their attention and they clicked through.

If you’re sending redirect or pop traffic the user most likely wasn’t expecting your ad at all.  Therefore you must do something drastic to grab their attention. 

There is all kinds of things you can do with mobile traffic, such as make their phone vibrate, play a sound, or use flashing / blinking graphics.  Just make sure to double-check with your traffic source to ensure you’re in compliance.

I will typically use a very strong hook to garner my user’s attention and bring them into my conversion funnel.  With a bit of research, I can normally narrow down what the end-user is doing when they come across my advertisement, and am able to leverage this to get their attention.

Are You Split Testing?

You will only get as much data as you allow yourself.  If you’re just grabbing one offer, throwing traffic at it, and are getting frustrated — then you’re not even giving it a fighting chance.  Maybe better off sticking to the lottery.

When I build out a campaign, it takes a little bit of pre-planning.  I try to split test as many things as I can.  From different types of banners to pre-landers to multiple offers.  The more options I give myself to gain a competitive advantage over the next person running, the better chance I have at finding a winning campaign.

Even if you have to pick a different offer category (but same geo location) – your’e going to give yourself another metric to compare it too.

My favorite type of “pre-lander” is the “survey style” but there are many ways you can do this.  One question per page, multiple questions per page, one offer at the end, multiple offers at the end.  Mix this stuff up and get creative! Even if something seems silly, don’t count it out until you test it.

After running a mobile performance marketing agency for over four years now, I’ve seen my fair-share of media buyers.  Before you come to the conclusion that the “offer sucks” or there is so big conspiracy going on with the advertiser, I highly suggest you look into your own campaign. Even though you don’t control the actual conversion page, there are many things you can do to your own campaign to get it to work.

I’m really hard-headed and will typically stick with a campaign until I figure out SOMETHING that works.  I hope you will also gain this type of competitiveness and will apply it to your campaigns!

Author RevMax

More posts by RevMax

Join the discussion 4 Comments